The argument essay asks you to take a defensible position and defend it with evidence and reasoning. It appears on both AP English Language and AP US Government — with one key difference in what counts as evidence.
What graders actually reward
Both versions share the same backbone: a defensible thesis that takes a clear, arguable position (not a summary, not a "both sides" hedge); specific evidence that supports it; and commentary that explains how the evidence proves the claim. Sophistication — the top rubric point — comes from a nuanced line of reasoning: addressing complexity, weighing a counterargument, or situating the issue in a broader context.
- AP Lang argument: evidence can come from your reading, studies, history, or observation — anything specific and relevant. Range and specificity beat one tired example.
- AP Gov argument: evidence must include at least one required foundational document (e.g., Federalist 10, the Constitution) or an approved Supreme Court case, plus a response to an alternate perspective.
The mistakes that cost the most points
- A wishy-washy thesis that refuses to take a side — the position must be arguable.
- Evidence without commentary — dropping a fact and moving on earns the evidence point at best.
- AP Gov: citing a document that isn't required, or forgetting to rebut the opposing view.
- Treating sophistication as vocabulary — it's a genuinely nuanced argument, not fancy words.
AimFive grades your argument essays point-by-point on the College Board rubric with published accuracy data — see exactly which rubric points you earned.
AP Lang Practice · AP Gov Practice · Rhetorical analysis
AP and Advanced Placement are trademarks of College Board. AimFive is not affiliated with or endorsed by College Board.
